Employee share plans represent one of the most powerful tools in a modern employer's arsenal, yet many businesses fail to harness their full potential.
While share plans are often associated with high-growth tech firms or publicly listed companies, a growing number of businesses across multiple sectors are embracing them as a tool to drive engagement and long-term loyalty.
When implemented successfully, they can transform your workplace culture, boost performance, and create a workforce genuinely invested in your company's success.
What are employee share plans?
An employee share plan is a scheme that allows staff to acquire shares in their employer’s business, either directly or through options that can be exercised at a later date. In some cases, shares are awarded based on individual or company performance; in others, employees are invited to buy shares – often at discounted rates or with tax advantages.
Employee share plans typically fall into three broad categories:
Share award schemes
Employees are granted shares outright, often subject to vesting conditions. These are usually treated as employment income unless part of a tax-advantaged plan.
Share option schemes
Employees are given the right to purchase shares at a fixed price in the future, often contingent on performance or tenure.
Share purchase schemes
Employees buy shares directly, sometimes through salary sacrifice, savings plans, or deferred payment arrangements. Each structure offers different levels of flexibility, risk, and reward – and choosing the right one depends on your company’s goals and workforce profile.
Types of share plans
Within these categories, the UK offers several specific schemes, including:
Share Incentive Plans (SIPs) – employees receive free shares or buy shares with the potential for matching shares from the employer, often with favourable tax treatment.
Enterprise Management Incentives (EMIs) – a flexible share option scheme designed for smaller, high-growth companies.
Company Share Option Plans (CSOPs) – formal share options typically aimed at middle to senior-level staff.
Long-Term Incentive Plans (LTIPs) – share awards that vest based on performance over several years, usually for senior roles.
Each scheme offers different benefits, tax treatments and legal implications, so selecting the right one depends on your company’s structure, size and goals. What they all have in common is the ability to give employees a genuine financial stake in the success of the business.
Why share plans work: the business case for equity participation
The most compelling argument for employee share plans lies in their ability to align interests across the organisation. When employees hold shares, they naturally become more invested in decisions that affect company performance. This shift in perspective can lead to increased productivity and a stronger focus on long-term value creation.
Consider the psychological impact of ownership. Employees who own shares are more likely to think twice before wasting resources, more inclined to suggest cost-saving measures, and more committed to delivering exceptional customer service. They understand that their actions directly impact their own financial wellbeing, creating a powerful incentive for excellence.
Share plans also serve as effective retention tools. Employees with share options or unvested shares (shares that have been promised to an employee but are not yet fully owned by them) have a financial incentive to remain with the company, reducing turnover costs and preserving institutional knowledge. This is particularly valuable for key personnel whose departure could significantly impact business operations.
From a recruitment perspective, well-structured share plans can differentiate your company from competitors. Top talent increasingly seeks opportunities that offer genuine wealth-building potential, and share plans provide exactly that. They signal confidence in your company's future and demonstrate a commitment to sharing success with those who help create it.
Getting the design right
The success of any employee share plan hinges on thoughtful design and clear communication. Start by defining your objectives clearly. Are you primarily focused on retention, motivation, recruitment, succession planning, or wealth sharing? Different goals may require different plan structures or a combination of plans.
One of the most important design decisions is whether to implement a scheme that is approved by HMRC. Approved schemes, such as EMIs and CSOPs, offer favourable tax treatment – typically deferring tax until shares are sold and applying capital gains tax (CGT) rather than income tax. In contrast, unapproved schemes may trigger income tax and National Insurance contributions when options are exercised, which can significantly reduce the net benefit to employees.
Employers should weigh the flexibility of unapproved schemes against the financial advantages of approved ones, especially when targeting high-value or long-term incentives.
Eligibility criteria also play a crucial role in plan effectiveness. For example, EMI schemes are only available to companies with fewer than 250 employees and gross assets under £30 million and are restricted to certain sectors. Participants must meet minimum working hours and cannot hold more than 30% of the company’s share capital. These rules ensure EMI schemes are targeted at growth-focused businesses and key contributors.
While broad-based plans can boost company-wide engagement, targeted plans for key performers or critical roles may deliver better results with limited resources. Consider implementing tiered approaches that provide different levels of participation based on role, performance, or tenure.
Vesting schedules require careful calibration. Too short, and you lose the retention benefit; too long, and employees may become disengaged. Many successful companies use graded vesting over three-to-five years, with accelerated vesting for exceptional performance or upon certain company milestones.
Performance conditions can significantly enhance plan effectiveness by ensuring share awards are earned rather than simply granted. Link vesting to metrics that matter most to your business – revenue growth, profitability, customer satisfaction scores, or market share gains. This approach reinforces the connection between individual effort and company success.
Communication matters
Even the most well-designed share plan will fail without proper communication and education. Employees need to understand not just the mechanics of their share plan, but its value and how their actions can influence outcomes. Regular communication from HR, online resources, and statements showing potential value can maintain engagement throughout the plan lifecycle.
Be transparent about risks as well as rewards. Share values can decline as well as rise, and employees should understand this reality. Balanced communication builds trust and sets realistic expectations, preventing disappointment that could undermine the plan's motivational impact.
Consider appointing share plan champions within different departments who can answer questions and reinforce key messages. These internal advocates often prove more effective than formal communications from leadership teams as they speak the language of their colleagues and understand their specific concerns.
Compliance and equality considerations
Companies must ensure their share plans comply with equality legislation; treating all eligible employees fairly, regardless of protected characteristics. This means examining eligibility criteria, performance metrics, and communication methods for potential bias. Regular reviews of participation rates and outcomes across different employee groups can identify issues before they become problems.
Professional advice is essential given the complexity of share plan legislation. Tax implications, regulatory reporting requirements, and corporate governance considerations all require specialist expertise. The cost of professional guidance is typically far outweighed by the risks of non-compliance or poorly structured plans.
At its heart, an employee share plan offers more than just a tax advantage – they help to build trust, transparency, and shared success. When people feel like they’re truly part of something, they show up differently. They care more, contribute more, and stick around for the long haul.
Whether you're looking to boost retention, attract top talent, or simply build a stronger, more connected team, giving employees a stake in your business can be a game-changer. But like any good strategy, it works best when it’s thoughtfully designed and clearly communicated.
Looking to find your next role, or the right professionals for your organisation? Get in touch with our recruitment specialists today.
